After MAC’s Penultimate eyeliner totally failed me (I’ll spare you the details), I needed a new liquid liner. When in Ulta last week, I spotted NYX Collection Noir Liquid Liner ($6), part of a new microcollection called Collection Noir. I got the impression that this mini-collection was a more upscale alternative to their traditional liners. I didn’t want to drop a ton of cash on the liner (because liquid liners rarely seem to work for me), so I figured this was a good choice.
I am SO glad I bought this liner. It has the fine brush applicator that’s so crucial to getting a precise winged eye. For some reason, I cannot replicate this look with pen-style liners, no matter how many different ways I apply it. With just one flick of my wrist, I was able to create a tapered cat-eye with whisper-thin ends. The formula is thick enough so that it didn’t run all over my lids when I applied it, but it wasn’t at all goopy or clumpy, either. The application is super smooth, and I don’t have to touch up with a cotton swab after. The tip is really thin, which makes it draw precise, even lines. And once it’s dry, it stays put; no smudging, transferring, or fading. It does take a few seconds to dry; I tried to curl my lashes right after applying it the first time, and ended up with black eyelids. But waiting a few seconds is a small price to pay for a liner this reliable.
You can see in the photo above that straight out of the tube, the brush does have a little excess product on it. I purposely took this picture to show you that one quick sweep against the lip of the tube removes the extra liner, and leaves you with the right amount of product.
If you’re looking for a liquid liner, I would absolutely recommend this one. It’s by far the best drugstore version I’ve encountered. There are certain products that are worth splurging on (for example, an amazing mascara or foundation), but for me, liquid liner isn’t one of them. This NYX liner let me draw dramatic cat-eyes that were simple to apply, and it was very easy on my wallet (yay!). This is definitely a Recession Beauty pick that rivals its pricier competitor products.
Not into liquid liner? The collection of black liners also includes Skinny Liner, Glossy Liner, Kohl Kajal Liner, Matte Liner, Satin Finish Liner, and Powder Liner (similar to an eyeshadow liner that creates soft, diffused lines that easily blend). All liners in the collection are $6.













